Pierrot Awards Best Supporting Actress in a Play
2018
| Melissa Whitworth | On Golden Pond - Chelsea Thayer Wayne |
2017
| Keisha Gill McNair | One Man, Two Guvnors - Dolly |
2016
| Ingrid MacDonald | Handle With Care - Edna |
2015
| Kaylee Bledsoe | Second Samuel - Omaha |
2014
| Bonnie Jean | Don't Dress for Dinner - Suzette |
2012
| Lori L. Engler | Rumors - Chris Gorman |
2011
| Suzanne Clark | Note |
2005
| Jenny Buchanan | The Odd Couple - Gwendolyn Pigeon |
2004
| Katie Beth McPhail | Over the Tavern - Annie |
