Pierrot Awards Best Actress in a Play
2018
| Candace Resmondo | The MOMologues - Charlotte | Note |
| Suzanne Clark | The MOMologues - Ellen | Note |
| Jessica Pipkin | The MOMologues - Maria | Note |
| Katria A. Harper | The MOMologues - Stefanie | Note |
2017
| Alexandra Rose Horton | Peter and the Starcatcher - Molly Aster |
2016
| Lori L. Engler | Handle With Care - Ayelet |
2015
| Darian Henne | Becky's New Car - Becky (Rebecca) Foster |
2014
| Cheyenne Grantham | The Miracle Worker - Annie Sullivan |
2012
| Karissa Barber | It's a Wonderful Life - Mary (Hatch) Bailey |
2011
| Lora Slavik | Dearly Departed - Raynelle |
2009
| Lori L. Engler | The Perfect Wedding - Julie |
2004
| Brenda Gibbs | Over the Tavern - Ellen Pazinski |
