Pierrot Awards Best Actress in a Musical
2019
| Sara Catherine Barnes | The Little Mermaid - Ursula |
2018
| Sharon Clark | Mamma Mia! - Donna Sheridan |
2017
| Bayley True | Disney's Beauty and the Beast - Belle |
2016
| Courtney Moore-Johnson | Singin' in the Rain - Kathy Selden |
| Laura Modrall | Singin' in the Rain - Lina Lamont |
2015
| Melissa Whitworth | Mary Poppins - Mary Poppins |
| Sarah Beth Ganey | Annie Get Your Gun - Winnie Tate |
2014
| Sara Catherine Barnes | Les Miserables - Madame Thenardier |
| Jessica Judy | Les Miserables - Eponine |
| Karissa Barber | Les Miserables - Fantine |
2013
| Sara Catherine Barnes | Annie - Grace |
| Stephanie Coatney | 9 to 5 - Doralee |
2012
| Lauren Maldonado | The Marvelous Wonderettes - Betty Jean | Note |
| Sarah Carey | The Marvelous Wonderettes - Cindy Lou | Note |
| Jennifer Mandala-Gravel | The Marvelous Wonderettes - Missy | Note |
| Virginia Zechiel | Buddy: The Buddy Holly Story - Vi Petty |
| Jessica Pipkin | The Marvelous Wonderettes - Suzy | Note |
2011
| Shelly Fountain | Note |
| Karissa Barber | Note |
| Karissa Barber | The Sound of Music - Maria Rainer |
2010
| Lori L. Engler | Gypsy - Adult Louise |
2009
| Melissa Davis | Kiss Me, Kate - Lois Lane/Bianca Minola |
2005
| Dena Kology | My Fair Lady - Eliza Doolittle |
| Jan Perez | My Fair Lady - Mrs Pearce |
2004
| Maria Adessa | Nuncrackers - Sister Mary Regina |
| Shelly Fountain | Always, Patsy Cline - Unknown |
